Facebook crushes Instagram on raw reach — but Instagram's typical Reel actually beats Facebook's typical Reel. Use Facebook to swing for reach; use Instagram to build dependable engagement.
◆ The read
Why this happened. Facebook's 36,513 average views per Reel is dragged up by a few mega-hits — its typical Reel only gets 850 views. Instagram spreads attention more evenly, so its typical Reel (1,391) actually beats Facebook's even though Facebook crushes it on totals.
Why the gap exists. Facebook has a much larger general news audience in our region, and its recommendation system is willing to push a single Reel into millions of feeds when early signals are strong — that is how a handful of hits create the huge total. Instagram's system is more cautious: it tests each post on a small audience and only expands the ones that hold attention, so few Reels run away with it but most get a fair shot.
In plain English. Facebook is feast-or-famine: most Reels are quiet, a few go enormous. Instagram is steadier: most Reels get a respectable run, but very few break out. Use Facebook to swing for reach; use Instagram to build dependable, engaged audience.
What this means for planning. Aim Facebook posts at the widest possible hook — a simple emotional payoff, a universal claim, a number anyone can grasp. Aim Instagram posts at a recognisable look and a clear theme, because every Instagram post is pulling roughly its weight and consistency compounds.